12th grade ELA

Senior Presentation Rubric

Criteria

Ratings

Points

Introduction/Thesis

4.0 pts

3.0 pts

2.0 pts

1.0 pts

0.0

4.0 pts

The introduction is inviting and compelling. The issue is clearly identified, and a convincing position on the issue is strongly articulated. Precise claims in support of the thesis are introduced, and distinguished from counterclaims.

Exceeds Expectations

Meets Expectations

Developing Expectations

Initiating Expectations

Neglecting Expectations

Threshold: 3.0 pts

Main Claims/Development

4.0 pts

3.0 pts

2.0 pts

1.0 pts

0.0

Claims are clearly articulated and explained, anticipating the audience's knowledge level and concerns. Each claim is supported by evidence and reasoning. Strengths and limitations of claims and counterclaims are pointed out. Claims clearly support the thesis.

Exceeds Expectations

Meets Expectations

Developing Expectations

Initiating Expectations

Neglecting Expectations

Threshold: 3.0 pts

Conclusion

4.0 pts

3.0 pts

2.0 pts

1.0 pts

0.0

The conclusion highlights key points, and supports the argument. The final appeal leaves the audience with a lasting impression.

Exceeds Expectations

Meets Expectations

Developing Expectations

Initiating Expectations

Neglecting Expectations

Threshold: 3.0 pts

Command of Language

4.0 pts

3.0 pts

2.0 pts

1.0 pts

0.0

Uses sophisticated words, phrases, and clauses to accurately create a cohesive argument. Clarifies relationships between claims, evidence, and reasoning. Maintains a formal, objective tone. Avoids errors in grammar and diction.

Exceeds Expectations

Meets Expectations

Developing Expectations

Initiating Expectations

Neglecting Expectations

Threshold: 3.0 pts

Verbal Delivery

4.0 pts

3.0 pts

2.0 pts

1.0 pts

0.0

Uses strong projection and clear articulation. Delivery is fluent, with an engaging pace, tempo, and vocal variety. Pitch, tone, and volume are used to emphasize important words or ideas.

Exceeds Expectations

Meets Expectations

Developing Expectations

Initiating Expectations

Neglecting Expectations

Threshold: 3.0 pts

Nonverbal Delivery

4.0 pts

3.0 pts

2.0 pts

1.0 pts

0.0

Eye contact with audience members is used early and often. Posture is professional and poised, and movement is precise and purposeful.

Exceeds Expectations

Meets Expectations

Developing Expectations

Initiating Expectations

Neglecting Expectations